The SDLP Assembly member who misleads on demography

Tags

birth rate, demographic decline in Northern Ireland, DENI, Dominic Bradley MLA, registrar general office, SDLP

Mr D Bradley: ……We know from the chief inspector’s report — which was debated earlier today — that many post-primary schools, particularly in the non-selective sector, are continuing to feel the effects of demographic decline. Enrolment figures have dropped by almost 4,000, and more than one third of schools have fewer than 500 pupils, which is potentially disastrous. Demographic decline is going to worsen over the next few years, which will lead to unplanned outcomes in the form of school closures in some areas. We need to act now before that situation occurs.

Perhaps Mr Bradley MLA  should study the Quarterly Report of the Registrar General before parroting the mantra of the DENI on their outdated rationale for schools estate change. The birth rate in Northern Ireland can be easily followed in the graph below.

THe Rise in the Birth Rate

Advertisements

Why no regulated Transfer Test? The Minister has failed.

Tags

Caitriona Ruane, DENI, post-primary education, transfer from primary school, transfer system

Caitriona Ruane’s excuse for the continued deregulated and chaotic vacuum in post-primary transfer arrangements has been made clear in answer to a question put by an assembly member

Post-Primary Transfer: CCEA Test

Mr W Clarke asked the Minister of Education to detail why she has withdrawn the test that CCEA had been developing.

(AQO 2304/09)

Minister of Education: Is é an t-aon bhealach amháin gur féidir teist a chur ar fáil ar bhonn freagrach, ná creatlach reachtach a chur léi a mhíníonn cén dóigh a n-úsáidfear í.

The only way a test could responsibly be made available is if there is a legislative framework defining its use. The successful operation of an admission-determining test requires not just a test, but a legal framework providing for which schools can and cannot use it, stating exactly how it should and should not be used and also stating that it alone should be used.

The test was a contingency for an agreement. My proposals featured a test in the interests of compromise and to give grammar schools three years to adjust to a long-term future without any selection and without any test. The reason that will not now happen is because others were not capable of equivalent concessions.

Minister Ruane’s warped thinking is exposed in her answer. She had hoped to gain political consensus from her victims, the grammar schools and those who believe in a choice for a grammar school, via their political representatives, to agree their own suicide.

Her effort has rightly failed but it remains her responsibility and duty of care to uphold the rights of children and their parents to a form of schooling which meets their needs. Ms Ruane continues to preside over a failed administration. It is unfortunate that her political opponents have been unable to outwit her.

Parents: Are You Being Heard by Minister Ruane?

Tags

Assembly questions on education, BBC Folks on the Hill, Caitriona Ruane, certainty on post-primary transfer, DENI, post primary transfer, post-primary education

The following question and reply appear in the Answer Booklet on the Northern Ireland Assembly website.

Post Primary Transfer

Mr S Moutray asked the Minister of Education how many complaints she has received from parents about post primary transfer arrangements in the last year (i) in total; (ii) broken down by constituency; and (iii) broken down by council area

(AQW 6138/09)

Minister of Education: Tá méid suntasach chomhfhreagrais faighte agam i rith na tréimhse seo maidir le hábhar an aistrithe iarbhunscoile, agus in alán cásanna, bíonn tuismitheoirí agus eile ar lorg léiriúcháin faoi shonruithe um fhorbairt mo mholtaí ar an aistriú iarbhunscoile agus le déanaí ar fhoilsiú na Treoir um Aistriú 2010.

I have received a considerable volume of correspondence on the subject of post-primary transfer during this period, and in many instances parents and others are seeking clarification on points of details about the development of my proposals for post-primary transfer and in more recent times the publishing of Transfer 2010 guidance. Correspondence of this nature is not routinely classified by any category and may take the form of enquiries, supportive or negative comments, or personal views on a way forward. On occasions parental correspondence includes a request for me to bring certainty to bear on arrangements for Transfer 2010. It is a subjective judgement as to whether correspondence of this nature should be described as letters of complaint, and in an increasing number of instances parental correspondence takes the form of an e-mail which contains no address details, hence precluding any analysis by constituency or council area. The information requested is therefore not readily available.

If the minister won’t listen to her travel agent or car mechanic on transfer and tests as parodied in the BBC The Folks on the Hill,

what chance have mere parents?

The Cardinal’s visit to the Northern Ireland Assembly

Tags

Cardinal Brady, Catholic Bishops, educa, Education Committee, education correspondent, Northern Ireland Assembly

on Wednesday March 18th was an important event in the passage of the Education and Skills Bill through the political arena.

Cardinal Brady and the Bishop Donal McKeown led Catholic Commission have stepped on to the big stage on the education issue by citing in their evidence to the Northern Ireland Assembly Education Committee nothing less than the European Convention on Human Rights.

The First Protocol (1952) to the European Convention on Human Rights includes the right to education (article 2):

No person shall be denied the right to education. In the exercise of any functions which it assumes in relation to education and to teaching, the State shall respect the right of parents to ensure such education and teaching in conformity with their own religious and philosophical convictions.

Implementation of the Convention is ensured through cases brought before the European Court of Human Rights.

Now the Cardinal wishes the Education Committee to respect the rights of the Catholic Church during consideration of the ESA bill on religious belief grounds, including estate and employment matters, while at the same time ignoring  the rights of parents with respect to their philosophical convictions on the matter of academic selection and grammar schools.

 Cardinal Brady’s Church has declared academic selection “immoral”.

It may be helpful to revisit a PACE commentary on the Catholic Church’s selective position on social justice from early 2008

https://paceni.wordpress.com/wp-admin/post.php?action=edit&post=3

What the Revised Curriculum has given society

Tags

all about me, Dr Carol Craig, Northern Ireland schools, QUB school of psychology, revised curriculum, school curriculum

Can it be any surprise to parents and society that changes in the school curriculum has given rise to a generation of children who have developed an “al about me” mentality?

Dr Carol Craig said children were being over-praised and schools needed to reclaim their role as educators, not psychologists.

Since 2007, there has been a statutory responsibility on schools in England to improve pupils’ well-being and primary and secondary schools are increasingly teaching social and emotional skills.

It is possible that DENI ETI inspectors will soon appraise schools’ performance in this area; and well-being could be one of the measures used in the school report card system that Caitriona Ruane wants to introduce.

Dr Craig told head teachers that this was not the role of schools.

“Schools have to hold out that they are educational establishments,” she said.

“They are not surrogate psychologists or mental health professionals.”

Learning about feelings from a professional in a classroom did not send out a positive message, she added.

And she warned there was a danger the more schools taught emotional well-being, the less parents would take responsibility.

“We run the risk of undermining the family as the principal agent of sociability,” she said.

 

It seems the message has not reached Ms Ruane’s DENI, in fact the Northern Ireland educationalists  could be described as evangelists in this field.

http://www.northernireland.gov.uk/news/news-de/news-de-120208-education-minister-puts.htm

PACE has issued warnings about the pilot of the revised curriculum, the Early Years Enriched Curriculum which was evaluated by none other than the Queen’s University School of Psychology.

http://www.psych.qub.ac.uk/Research/Centres/CALT/index.aspx

What a surprise that their self evaluation promoted the “all about me” mentality. Parents may now be asking – at what cost?

50,000 empty desks: How the DENI got it wrong

Tags

Barry Gardiner, birth rate, Caitriona Ruane, Minister for Education, Minister of Education, Northern Ireland schools, registrar general office, schools

Last year saw 25,600 births registered — the highest number recorded since 1991 and a massive 20% increase since 2002.

So say the figures from the Registrar General’s Office. The numbers are verified, accurate and not subject to political manipulation..

It is a pity for parents that the Department of Education for Northern Ireland were unable to use their skills to predict the impact for the furure of education provision. Many schools have been closed as part of the DENI rationalisation plan and no doubt heavy expenditure will have to take place in order to accomodate demand in the next few years.

Perhaps the reader can follow the trend line and tell the DENI which direction the trend is headed.

http://www.nisra.gov.uk/archive/demography/publications/qtr_report/qtr3_2008.pdf

Barry Gardiner, former Minister of Education, issued a press release stating: http://www.deni.gov.uk/consultationpaper.pdf 

Demographic Decline the lowest ever seen in Northern Ireland. 

 The decline in the population of pre-school children has been significant in recent years. Until 2001/02 the size of the pre-school cohort was usually between 24,000 and 25,000 children. In 2002/03 it fell to undern23,500, and is expected to continue declining until at least 2010, when it will have reduced to around 21,000. The current birth rate, at 1.8 children per female, is down from 2.5 per female 20 years ago and is and is the lowest ever seen in Northern Ireland.

Getting it wrong is a speciality subject for Ministers of Education. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

How the Department of Education misleads

Tags

11-plus, Caitriona Ruane, ccea test, DENI, FOI, Minister of Education, regulated tests at 11, transfer from primary school, transfer test, Will Haire

During her announcement denying parents a regulated measure of their child’s attainment at primary school the education minister stated:

“I will not do it. The test has been cancelled,”

“To simply make a test available and not have a legal framework to define its use would be highly |irresponsible.”

Caitriona Ruane MLA , Minister for Education Northern Ireland Assembly

March 10,2009

On 16th May 2008 the promise to parents was very different.

NI’s education minister has faced the assembly’s education committee about her plans for primary school transfer.

Caitríona Ruane aims to extend academic selection for three years before ending it.

It will take the form of one hour-long test of literacy and numeracy, and it will be held in a grammar school.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/7404108.stm

The Minister sent instructions through the Permanent Secretary, Will Haire, outlining how CCEA were to proceed.

Asked for the specification under the Freedom of Information Act the CCEA refused.

In early February the Minister withdrew her “regulated test” costing the taxpayer over £100,000

So who’s being irresponsible Minister Ruane?

Ruane: the Rejectionist Minister of Education

Tags

BBC, Caitriona Ruane, CCEA, DENI, Northern Ireland Assembly, regulated tests at 11, unregulated system

The Education Minister, Caitriona Ruane, continued with her ideological agenda today by refusing to reintroduce the CCEA test she commissioned and abandoned  at great taxpayer expense.

The BBC story http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/7934973.stm tells of Ruane’s refusal to return to a regulated system of transfer based upon attainment in numeracy and literacy.

As ever the ex-professional tennis player returned the concerns of P6 parents with a volley of snide shots including one that placed the blame on unnamed schools.

She had  denied threatening schools but said a small number were “blocking change”.

So Caitriona Ruane is against unregulated tests and against regulated tests. She is also clearly against parental wishes for their children

A Solution for Parents: Talk with your feet

Tags

11-plus, ATL, Carryduff, Millennium Integrated Primary, Minister of Education, selection at 11, withdrawal of pupils

In a dramatic fashion one Northern Ireland Primary School demonstrated that they understand who they work for and who controls their school – the parents.

Parents have withdrawn their children from the  County Down primary school.

The parents at Millennium Integrated Primary in Carryduff believed the school was not going to teach pupils for a replacement to the 11 plus.

The school quickly sought to characterise the matter as a misunderstanding. Perhaps the management and teachers now understand that their various attempts to cajole, bully and mislead parents on behalf of their unions and the DENI can be easily remedied by a simple action by parents – withdrawal of children.

 In their rapid response to the removal of the pupils  the Millennium Integrated Primary have demonstrated that the ” misunderstanding” was nothing of the sort. Indeed the position is now further complicated by their claim to be:

” preparing pupils for up to three different sorts of exams to cover the diversity of its pupil population.”

The only exam to be prepared for is the AQE numeracy and literacy test which is a part of the revised curriculum.

The so-called NFER verbal reasoning tests offered by the Catholic schools can only be coached for by ignoring some other aspect of the curriculum. The Minister has made clear that her Inspectorate will take action if this occurs.

Since the Education Minister withdrew her CCEA commissioned test and no specification has ever been revealed for it then Millennium Integrated Primary are further mistaken in telling the BBC that they are preparing children for a third exam.

The nonsense and misinformation spouted by the teachers’ union, the Association of Teachers and Lecturers, is exemplified by the statement to its members claiming “it is illegal to divert from the new primary school curriculum during school hours to coach for the new tests.”

PACE suggests that the union place a call to the DENI to check the law.

Well done Carryduff parents. The answer for other concerned P6 parents is obvious. If you have concerns about teachers willingness to prepare your child for numeracy and literacy testing – move your child to a school which is prepared to teach.

Stanley Poots and the ESA

Tags

11-plus, academic selection, ESA, ESA Working Group for Children's Services, Gavin Boyd, Stanley Poots

While Stanley Poots is fronting yet another campaign against academic selection to post-primary schools he remains quiet over his role with the Education and Skills Authority.

Mr Poots was appointed to Gavin Boyd’s ESA Working Group for Children’s Services. 

The Terms of Reference can be found here.

http://www.esani.org.uk/docs/childrens_services_terms_of_reference.pdf

Nowhere does it state that Mr Poots was to evangelise for Gavin Boyd’s anti-selection manifesto.

Mr Poots gave an interview withe local media in which he stated:

“All schools – primary, secondary and grammar – agreed that the 11-plus test was flawed and should be abolished”

Parents can only speculate as to when Mr Poots came by his now publicly expressed views.

So whose frustration are you expressing Stanley? It wouldn’t be Gavin’s would it?